July 17, 2018

Session 54 is about the Dark Night of the Soul.  Interestingly, the retreat leaders clarified that for St. John of the Cross and Teresa of Avila, both Spanish speakers, dark meant obscure or hidden, like not being able to see at night.  It wasn’t “dark” like evil as we define the word today.

The Session is a discussion between Mary Anne Best and Gail Fitzpatrick-Hopler

Mary Anne begin by talking with Gail, “As you noted, the night of sense, when we’re in it, it may not look like a profound invitation from God, but it leads to deep healing and purification of our motivations in our hearts into all of the other fruits that were given by the spirit. I, myself, think of it as illuminations in the soul by God.”

Gail notes, “Interesting because I realized I had similar experience in that, and I suppose it’s an earmark of going deeper. The God I knew was gone and I didn’t feel anything, or I didn’t know anything anymore. And I didn’t seem to fit in with the rest of the people, with my peers and my family members. I felt separated in a certain kind of way. I felt really kind of perplexed and I was having some sort of, I would call it suffering, I was suffering internally in a way because of the losses.”

Gail later discusses our options during the experience of the dark night, “I think we just make the commitment to take ourselves to our prayer chair every morning and just sit down and do it. The whole idea of practice is we practice every day and we make the commitment to practice every day. It’s not about sitting down and feeling good. It’s about sitting down and deepening our relationship with God for the 20 minutes. We just take ourselves and do that and in faith believe that this is what we’re doing even if it doesn’t feel comfortable or right, we do it anyway. In fact, I think St. John of the Cross had said when your life is busy, and you feel discouraged, don’t do less prayer, do more. If you could add a few more minutes, just sit down and then take yourself back to your chair in the afternoon or early evening and do your practice and just get up from there, not trying to figure out what happened in the inner room or not trying to understand what’s going on per se, but just go about your life. And allow your life to show you markers about where you are in your relationship with God and others – and it will be an interesting experience but not to hold onto the time of prayer as like the place where you and God are working on something. It’s just an opening so that God can do the work. It’s really kind of a break. I remember one time, Father Thomas said to me, I don’t know, I said something about doing my Centering Prayer and he said to me, ‘Well, that’s kind of like a vacation, a vacation from yourself and you just sit down and it’s like a relief.’ That was another good tip for me and kind of helpful – a vacation from myself, a vacation from that constant inner chatter.”

The two close the discussion with this reading, “I have a little, another little reading from Invitation to Love that we can close with and I think it really affirms what we’ve been saying, ‘The night of sense enables us to face our distorted views of God and to lay them aside then we are free to relate to God as he is and to use the immense energy that this freedom releases to relate to others with respect and love. One way, God deals with the limits we have of relating to him is by reducing our concepts of him to silence. As resting in God as contemplative practice becomes habitual, we spontaneously disidentify with our emotional programs for happiness and our cultural conditioning. Already, we are meeting God at a deeper level. In time, we will grow from the reflective relationship with God to one of communion. The latter is of being to being, presence to presence relationship which is the knowledge of God in pure faith.’”

Session 55 continues with Father Keating explaining the process of the Dark Night of the Soul and the need to stay with the spiritual journey although it may be very difficult.  The retreat directors summarized Father Keating’s complex discussion well.  It follows:

“Once we start the healing process during the night of sense, the energy that previously went into satisfying the demands of the energy centers is freed up and becomes available for other purposes. We might say that instead of running on the energy of the false self we are running on divine energy. The freeing of this energy can be quite powerful and sometimes overwhelming, especially if we are not prepared for it. The Gospels suggest that we prepare ourselves by creating two banks in our lives, likes the banks of a stream, so that this energy can be channeled for our good. The first bank is created and maintained through the discipline of our practices and our devotion to God. The second bank is service of others through our state in life, our commitments, and perhaps some ministry. 

The two banks prepare us to channel the energy of what Fr. Thomas calls the unloading of the unconscious into higher levels of consciousness. The night of sense is a transitional stage in our growth and development where God shakes the ground on which we felt secure and opens us to new ways of seeing and experiencing reality. It is the interior silence, the resting in God, the opening in trust that enables the night of sense to begin its healing work. It is in this transitional stage that we begin to dis-identify with our emotional programs and with our cultural conditioning, which in early life formed our identity, our image of God, and our relationship with God. God relates to us wherever we are in our level of human development; the fruit of the night of sense is that we have the opportunity to relate to God in a new way, face to face, being to being, in pure faith. 

The night of sense challenges our commitment to the spiritual journey. Commitment in relationship, including our relationship with God, allows us to be vulnerable and let down our defenses, which sometimes causes the dark side of our personality to arise. This is our growing edge, part of the process of purification and transformation. This can be very painful, especially if we are experiencing aridity, that feeling that God is absent, and the loss of our previous spiritual consolations. We may start to have second thoughts about the path we have chosen. In today's video Fr. Thomas says, "If you ... walk away from your commitment to the spiritual journey, who goes with you? The false self, of course. And wherever you go, you take it and you just have to face it once again under some other circumstances, with some other community, or with some other person."

"God is calling us in the night of sense to take responsibility for ourselves and for our personal response to Christ's invitation to follow him. This includes our response to the people we live with and, ultimately, to the whole human family."
-- Thomas Keating, Invitation to Love 

Resources for Further Study: You may wish to read Chapter 11 - 14 in Invitation to Love (20th anniversary edition), Chapters 10 - 13 in older editions. 

You also may wish to read The Dark Night of the Soul by Gerald May.